Overview

Operational Resilience Engineering

Operational Resilience Engineering (ORE) is a developing research framework for understanding and improving engineering systems under disturbance, uncertainty, surprise, and changing operational demands.

Operations Research + Resilience Engineering = Operational Resilience Engineering

ORE connects vulnerability analysis, resilience engineering, operations research, and control theory. It is intended for critical infrastructure and other complex engineering systems in which performance depends on technical, human, organizational, and socio-technical processes.

The framework

ORE is organized around three linked but distinct analytical domains:

Vulnerability → Resilience → Control

Vulnerability concerns a system’s susceptibility to undesirable change. It identifies relevant scenarios, system states, likelihood information, consequences, operational boundaries, and the analytical perspectives used to evaluate them.

Resilience concerns a system’s ability to manage undesirable change. Resilient design concerns the engineering decisions through which that ability can be preserved or improved. ORE distinguishes design perspectives focused on robustness, rebound, extensibility, and evolvability, rather than treating them as interchangeable strategies.

Control concerns the continuing processes through which systems sense conditions, anticipate future challenges, act through feasible interventions, and learn from resulting performance.

This sequence is analytical rather than chronological. Vulnerability does not occur only before a disruption, resilience does not occur only during or after a disruption, and control is not merely a final implementation step. Together, they describe how a system can be evaluated, improved, and managed over time.

From data to decisions

A central ORE principle is:

Data → Perspective → Decisions

Engineering-system data do not independently determine a decision. Analysts must first interpret information about system states, likelihoods, consequences, performance, constraints, and feasible actions. That interpretation establishes a perspective through which vulnerabilities, resilience strategies, and control actions can be evaluated.

For example, the same vulnerability data can support distinct perspectives on risk, reliability, adversary, and safety. Those perspectives can preserve different information, prioritize different system conditions, and recommend different engineering designs. ORE therefore treats perspective as an explicit part of quantitative analysis rather than an implicit assumption.

The same principle applies to resilient design. Assessing how a system is operating and identifying what kinds of change are desirable are necessary steps in constructing a decision model. A numerical performance score alone does not specify which resilience strategy an engineer should pursue.

Current focus

The present formal foundation of ORE is quantitative vulnerability analysis. The developing theory defines a vulnerability space composed of scenarios, likelihood information, and consequence information:

\[\mathcal{V} = (S,L,C).\]

Within this framework, risk is one perspective on vulnerability rather than the general category for all vulnerability analysis. Reliability, adversary, and safety are likewise treated as distinct perspectives that can reveal different engineering-system concerns and decision tradeoffs.

A companion theory of resilient design is under development. It examines how interpretations of system performance and available engineering decisions shape the selection of robustness, rebound, extensibility, and evolvability strategies.

Future work will connect vulnerability analysis and resilient design to control processes organized around sensing, anticipating, acting, and learning. Detailed resilience formulations will be released with a public preprint.